Fixtures Phase|Step 14 of 27

Replace Toilet Handle

New handle makes an old toilet look refreshed. A small detail with big visual impact.

Time Required

10-15 minutes

Cost

$10-30

Difficulty

Very Easy

Before You Buy

Important: Most toilet handles are "universal" but check these things first:

• Side mount vs. front mount: Look at where your current handle sits
• Left-hand vs. right-hand thread: Most handles have reverse (left-hand) threads
• Tank style: Some older or designer toilets need specific handles

Classic, affordable, matches most bathrooms. $8-15

Hides fingerprints, modern look. $12-20

Bold, contemporary. Match to other fixtures. $15-25

Warm, traditional feel. $15-30

Not strictly necessary for this job, but prevents accidents if you bump the fill valve.

Lift straight up and set aside carefully. Porcelain is fragile and lids are expensive to replace.

Disconnect the chain from the handle lever inside the tank. Note which hole it's attached to.

Remember: Turn clockwise to loosen (reverse threads). Use adjustable pliers if needed.

Insert from outside, thread nut from inside (counterclockwise to tighten). Hand-tight plus quarter turn.

Hook chain to lever with about 1/2" slack. Test flush and adjust as needed.

Tighten the mounting nut from inside the tank (counterclockwise).

Chain has too much slack. Shorten by hooking it to a higher hole on the lever.

Chain is too short, holding flapper open. Add slack or use a lower hole.

•Match your other fixtures: Coordinate handle finish with towel bars, faucet, and cabinet hardware.
•Metal beats plastic: Spend a few extra dollars for a metal handle - plastic ones break and discolor.
•Take a photo: Snap a picture of the chain connection before removing so you remember the setup.
•Upgrade the flapper too: While you're in there, a new $5 flapper can stop running toilet issues.