Evaluate Existing Furniture
Not everything needs to go. Quality frames can last 25+ years and reupholstering costs less than buying new. The key is separating worn-out pieces from pieces that just need a refresh.
Time Required
30-60 minutes
Cost
$0
Difficulty
Easy
How to Assess Each Piece
Check the frame
Lift one front corner of the sofa 6 inches off the ground. If the other front leg lifts too, the frame is solid. If it stays down, the frame is broken or weak.
Test the cushions
Sit in every seat for a minute. Good cushions spring back when you stand. Foam that stays compressed is worn out. Cushion replacement costs $100-$300 per seat.
Evaluate the fabric
Fabric can always be changed. If the frame and cushions are good, reupholstering gives you a custom piece for $1,000-$3,000 — often less than a quality replacement sofa.
Consider the style
A structurally sound piece in an outdated style might still be worth keeping if a slipcover or reupholstery brings it into your new vision. Classic silhouettes are especially adaptable.
Keep, Refresh, or Replace?
Keep as-is:
- • Solid wood tables with good finish — just clean and polish
- • Bookshelves in good condition — restyle the contents instead
- • Accent chairs with classic shapes and intact upholstery
Refresh:
- • Good sofa frame with worn fabric → reupholster ($1,000-$3,000)
- • Dated wood tables → sand and refinish or paint ($50-$150 DIY)
- • Saggy cushions on a solid frame → replace foam inserts ($100-$300)
Replace:
- • Broken frames, wobbly joints, or structural damage
- • Particle board furniture that's swelling or delaminating
- • Pieces that don't fit the room size or layout needs
Pro Tips
- •Don't replace everything at once: Keep 1-2 anchor pieces and build around them. A room where everything is brand new can feel sterile.
- •Sell before you buy: List items on Facebook Marketplace or Craigslist 2-3 weeks before you need them gone. The proceeds fund new purchases.
- •Check construction quality: Kiln-dried hardwood frames, 8-way hand-tied springs, and high-density foam are signs of quality worth saving.