How to Refresh or Replace Your Mailbox
A mailbox greets every visitor and mail carrier daily. A rusty, dented, or faded mailbox suggests neglect. A fresh, substantial mailbox shows pride in your home.
Quick Summary
Time needed
1-2 hours
Cost
$50-$200
Difficulty
Easy
Paint or Replace?
Refresh with Paint
If mailbox is structurally sound but cosmetically tired
- • Clean with TSP solution
- • Sand to rough up surface
- • Prime with rust-inhibiting primer
- • Paint with outdoor metal paint
- • Apply new numbers/name
Replace Completely
If mailbox is dented, rusty, or cheaply made
- • Remove old mailbox/post
- • Install new 4x4 post in concrete
- • Mount quality mailbox
- • Add house numbers
- • Optional: planting bed at base
Choosing a New Mailbox
Post-Mount Traditional
Classic design. Choose heavy-duty metal or rust-resistant aluminum. Locking models prevent package theft. Price: $60-$150.
Modern Horizontal
Contemporary style, often stainless steel or powder-coated metal. Wall-mount or post-mount options. Price: $80-$200.
Decorative Column
Stone, brick, or composite column with integrated mailbox. Most substantial option, professional installation recommended. Price: $200-$800.
Style Tip: Match mailbox finish to your door hardware for a cohesive look. Matte black works with most home styles.
Installation Guidelines
USPS Requirements
- •Bottom of mailbox 41-45 inches from ground
- •6-8 inches back from curb edge
- •Door opens away from traffic
- •Numbers clearly visible from street
Post Replacement Steps
1. Dig 24-30 inch deep hole
Use post hole digger. Hole should be 3x wider than post (12-14 inches for 4x4 post).
2. Set post in concrete
Use 2-3 bags of quick-set concrete mix. Level post, support with braces, let cure 24-48 hours.
3. Mount mailbox at correct height
Measure 41-45 inches from ground to bottom of mailbox. Use quality screws, not nails.
4. Add finishing touches
Install house numbers, apply protective clear coat to post, plant flowers at base if desired.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do I need permission to replace my mailbox?
Check with your HOA if you have one - many have mailbox style restrictions. Also follow USPS guidelines: mailbox must be 41-45 inches from ground to bottom of mailbox, and the door must open away from the road. No permission needed from USPS to replace, but placement and height are regulated.
Ready for the Next Step?
Complete your entrance with a quality doormat layered for function and style.