Plan Phase|Step 4 of 27
Assess What Can Stay
If tile, tub, and toilet are in good shape, a refresh can work wonders for much less.
The Refresh vs. Renovation Decision
The key question: Are the bones of your bathroom in good shape? If tile, tub, toilet, and vanity cabinet are structurally sound, you can transform the space with a refresh instead of a costly renovation.
Rule of thumb: If 70% or more of your bathroom can stay, a refresh is the right choice. If you need to replace tub, tile, or vanity cabinet, you're looking at a renovation.
Assessment Checklist
Tile Condition
Keep: No cracks, grout can be cleaned or regrouted
Maybe: Minor chips, outdated color but not ugly
Replace: Cracked, loose, or water damage behind
Tub/Shower Condition
Keep: Surface in good shape, drains properly
Maybe: Stained surface (can be refinished for $300-600)
Replace: Cracked, leaking, or structurally damaged
Toilet Condition
Keep: Flushes well, no cracks or leaks
Maybe: Works but looks dated (consider new seat only)
Replace: Constantly running, cracked, or rocking
Vanity Cabinet
Keep: Structurally sound, can be painted if dated
Maybe: Doors damaged but cabinet box is good
Replace: Water damage, particle board falling apart
What a Refresh CAN Change
- Faucets and showerhead
- Towel bars and hardware
- Light fixtures
- Mirror
- Wall paint
- Toilet seat and handle
- Grout (clean or regrout)
- Caulking
Pro Tips
- •Check for water damage: Press walls and floors near tub. Soft spots mean bigger problems.
- •Test the exhaust fan: Hold tissue near it. If it doesn't pull, moisture is building up.
- •Look under the sink: Water stains or warped cabinet floor indicate leaks.
- •Check caulk carefully: Peeling caulk often hides mold underneath.